Your Creepypasta Love! Chapter 1

You wake up in Slenders mansion and you meet the boys who live there who each have a problem with no solution to them... Options of: Ben, Jeff, Toby, Jack, and Slender!

They’re counting on you to make the right decisions and for their problem to be fixed! If their problem is harder then so thought then they’ll still love you I’m sure!

Created by: The hatchet girl
  1. You blink awakening to 5 boys staring at you. “Wh-Who are y-you...?” You stammered in shock. “Good evening,” the figure who was conversing with you wore a black tuxedo and necktie. “The blonde Is Benjamin Drowned, White hooded killer is Jeff, Goggle boy is Ticci Toby, The mask boy is Eyeless Jack, And I’m Slenderman, nice to meet you!” He introduced. “Y-Y/N...” You stuttered. You had knew the Creepypasta’s but wouldn’t have thought they were real.
  2. Everyone seemed friendly and sweet! Ben was sitting down playing Zelda, Jeff was hanging around, Toby was in the corner staring at the wall, Eyeless Jack was eating what seemed to be a kidney, and Slenderman was at a desk doing paperwork. Who do you walk over to?
  3. If Ben: You walk over to Ben and sit next to him. “What’s wrong?” You ask. “I can’t seem to beat this guy...” He said struggling with Nintendo switch. “L-Let me help!” You hesitantly said pulling the Nintendo out from his hands. “Hey!” He pouted. You defeated the boss and handed the console back to Ben. “...” There was silence. “You are amazing!” He complimented.
  4. If Jeff: You walk over to Jeff and leaned on the wall next to him. “Sooo-“ He widened his eyes. “What are ya up to?” You ask. “None ya...!” He turned away facing his back towards you. “What’s wrong?” You ask. “Bored...” He replied. “Mk, ask me a question!” You exclaim. “Killing...?” He whispered in a boring tone. “_________” Whatever you said, it made him smile.
  5. If Toby: You sit down next to Toby which catches his eye. He looks at you then back at the wall. “What’s wrong?” “...” Silence. “Are you okay?” You ask. “No...” He mumbles. “Are you sad...?” You ask. “No...” He mumbles. “Are you dead...” You expected a ‘no’. “Yes...” He replied. “How did you die?” You asked. “I didn’t really die... If it wasn’t for Slender, I’d be burning in flames...” You thought he died in a car crash, and you were right. “Do you miss your family.....?” You asked. “Yes.... Yes I do...... I miss them with all my heart...” He started sobbing. You scoot closer and embrace him within your arms. He hugs you back but tighter. “Hey you know what! __________!” He smiled when you said that. “Thank you... thank you so much...!” He cried.
  6. If Jack: You sit beside him and stare at his bad manners. “Want some?” He asked. “No thanks...” You reply with a smile. “Oki Doki!” He continued. You squinted in disgust. He looks at you sadly and then swallows. “I know I’m messy...” He says. “I’m just nervous...” He said. “Why are you nervous?” Your nosiness kicked in. “I have a date tomorrow night with a girl I met...” He said. “That’s amazing!” You exclaim. “It should be... but... I have really bad manners....... plus the only thing I eat is kidneys so...” He says. “Hmmm? I got it! _________!” You say. “Thanks so much!” He says hugging you tight.
  7. If Slenderman: You walk over to Slenderman. “What ya doing?” You ask. “Doing paperwork.” He replied. “That’s a lot of paperwork...?” You say looking at the tower of paperwork stacked on his desk. “I know...” He complained. “What’s wrong?” You ask. “I’m stressed... My job makes me do other people’s paperwork and it’s irritating...” He says honestly. “________” You whisper. Your idea catches his attention. “You are a good little human aren’t you...?” He said.
  8. It is supper time and Sally wants you to play with her. “Choose someone else to be the prince!” Sally pouted as you think. “*sigh* ______...” You say blushing. “Oki Doki!” Sally ran out and pulled ______ into the room.
  9. “So uh Y/N? Why’d ya bring me here?” ______ asked. “Sorry, but I had to choose a prince!” You say. You both chuckle. “I’m gonna go use the bathroom!” Sally ran to the bathroom. “So uh who’s the princess?” ______ asked. “M-Me...” they lifted your chin so you would be staring into their eyes. They closed their eyes and leaned closer.
  10. It was time for bed but you don’t have a room. Who would you cuddle with? (NOT THAT THING WEIRDO’S!)
  11. Did you enjoy? If so chapter two is coming out soon!

Rate and Share this quiz on the next page!
You're about to get your result. Then try our new sharing options. smile

What is GotoQuiz? A fun site without pop-ups, no account needed, no app required, just quizzes that you can create and share with your friends. Have a look around and see what we're about.

Quiz topic: My Creepypasta Love! Chapter 1

Trending Quizzes

See More

Special Feature

Try the top political quiz on GoToQuiz to find where you fall on on multiple axes, then compare your results to others'.

We're Testing

Send Feedback about GoToQuiz, report a bug or error, make a suggestion!

Home
Search
Trending